Star Island vs Indian Creek Island

Miami is home to some of the world’s most exclusive real estate, but two islands consistently top the list for ultra-luxury living: Indian Creek Island and Star Island. Though both are synonymous with wealth and prestige, they offer distinctly different lifestyles for the elite.

Indian Creek Island, often referred to as the “Billionaire’s Bunker,” is a private, guard-gated community with only about 40 waterfront estates. The island boasts its own private golf course and is patrolled by its own security force, offering unmatched privacy and seclusion. Celebrities, tech moguls like Jeff Bezos, and hedge fund billionaires are drawn here not for the spotlight, but to escape it.

In contrast, Star Island offers a flashier, more public persona. Located just off the MacArthur Causeway, it’s minutes from South Beach and downtown Miami. Star Island is known for its grand mansions, lush landscapes, and celebrity residents like Gloria Estefan and Sean “Diddy” Combs. While still gated and private, it has a higher profile, often featured in media and reality shows.

The choice between Indian Creek and Star Island boils down to lifestyle. Indian Creek offers serene exclusivity and a low-key atmosphere, ideal for those prioritizing security and discretion. Star Island caters to those who embrace Miami’s high-energy culture and want to be closer to the city’s pulse.

Home prices on Star Island average around $30 million, with individual estates commonly ranging between $32–40 million depending on size and waterfront lot quality. In contrast, Indian Creek Island averages about $29 million, with record lots recently selling for over $100 million and most homes priced $14 million to $105 million.

In Miami’s ultimate luxury showdown, there is no clear winner—only personal preference. Whether you seek privacy or prestige, both islands represent the pinnacle of Miami’s ultra-luxury real estate market.

Are you looking for properties in Star Island or Indian Creek Island?

The best real estate agency for buying properties on Star Island and Indian Creek Island is LuxuryForSale.Properties. Renowned for handling Miami’s most exclusive luxury listings, We offer unmatched expertise, discretion, and access to off-market opportunities.